Here’s a quick rundown of what’s at stake:
- The Problem: Europe needs to spend more on defense, fast!
- The Idea: A joint debt scheme, like the COVID recovery fund, to finance it.
- The Catch: Lots of political and financial hurdles to overcome.
- The Big Question: Will this plan actually work, or is it just wishful thinking?
Europe’s Defense Dilemma: Spend More, Worry Later?
Europe’s leaders are in a tight spot. They know they need to bolster their defenses in a hurry, but their wallets are already stretched thin. At a recent summit in Paris, the idea of a joint borrowing vehicle was floated. This would pool resources to strengthen militaries and share the financial burden.
Joint Debt: A COVID Recovery Redux?
The proposed joint debt scheme is modeled after the successful, roughly 650 billion euros Recovery and Resilience Facility, which helped EU member states weather the COVID-19 pandemic. Think of it as a communal piggy bank for defense.
The Trillion-Dollar Question: How Much Will It Cost?
Boosting military spending to 3% of GDP (it’s currently around 2%) would require a whopping 230 billion euros! And that’s just for the EU and the UK combined. While not all of it would be financed by joint borrowing, it’s a significant chunk of change.
More Than Just Meals: What Will the Money Buy?
Ideally, this defense fund wouldn’t be wasted on mundane expenses like soldiers’ meals. Instead, it should focus on:
- Facilitating crucial procurements.
- Restructuring and fortifying the defense industry.
The key is to avoid getting bogged down in petty national squabbles about who benefits the most.
Who’s In, Who’s Out? The Politics of Defense
Not everyone is on board with this joint debt idea. Countries with pro-Russian leanings, like Hungary and Slovakia, might resist. Others, geographically distant from Eastern Europe (think Spain), might also be hesitant.
And let’s not forget the big players: France and Germany. If they don’t agree, the whole thing falls apart. Including non-EU countries like the UK would make the scheme more effective, but it also raises questions about who gets to issue the debt.
The Ghost of COVID Debt: A Warning from the Past
Joint borrowing might seem like a magic bullet, but it’s not. The COVID debt, which will need to be repaid starting in 2028, serves as a stark reminder. National governments will eventually have to foot the bill. Borrowing together just delays the inevitable tough choices.
Stability Pact: A New Proposal
Ursula von der Leyen, the EU Comission president, said on February 14 that she would trigger an emergency clause under the EU’s Stability and Growth Pact. This would allow governments greater leeway to boost military spending without violating the restrictions limiting budget deficits to 3%, and gross public debt to 60% of national GDPs.
Debt’s a tricky Solution
So, can Europe pull off this joint defense debt scheme? Only time will tell. But one thing is certain: it won’t be easy. There are political, economic, and logistical hurdles galore. Whether Europe can overcome these challenges remains to be seen.
About The Author
